Our Team


Dennis Zubler Agency Principal

Dennis started his career in the insurance industry in 1980. Over the years, he worked as an insurance agent, agency manager, and marketing representative for three insurance companies before going to Hornafius Insurance Agency, Inc. in 1984. Dennis purchased the agency in 1995. The business has grown significantly since that time. Dennis has been very involved in the communities where he lives and works. He has also been very involved regionally, nationally, and internationally through his involvement in Rotary International. Since 2002, Dennis takes on the persona of Itzy the clown and tries to bring joy, smiles and laughs to others. In addition to enjoying working with associates and clients of Hornafius Insurance Agency, he loves his family. After raising two grown children, he takes pleasure in watching his four grandchildren grow up. Dennis is a Penn State graduate with a degree in accounting. He enjoys college and professional football and has been a Steeler fan since watching pro football in the 1960’s.


Phone 717-367-5126



Valerie May Client Care Specialist

Personal Lines

Val began her insurance career with Hornafius Insurance Agency in 2009. Prior to this, she spent 12 years in the Real Estate industry. Val’s first four years were spent in the Apartment Building Division and she currently assists in the Personal Lines Division. She grew up in Highspire and moved to Elizabethtown in 1996. Val loves spending time with her two kids, fishing, and having cookouts with family.


Phone 717-367-5126

Text 717-308-9711



Rebecca Keiter Client Care Specialist

Commercial Lines

Rebecca began her career in insurance in 1994. She has worked in two independent insurance agencies prior to joining Hornafius Insurance Agency in 2014. Rebecca is a licensed agent and holds the insurance designation of Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR). While she enjoys many music genres, she most often listens to country music. She loves the spring weather despite allergies that might make it difficult to enjoy the warmth.


Phone 717-367-5126

Text 717-308-9713